My daughter has had both and says she prefers Direct TV. I just dropped Comcast and went with Dish Network, mostly because they gave me the best deal. I haven't had any problems with it so far and we get a lot of rain and clouds. I get a lot more channels for my money than I did with Comcast, but everything seems to work a little slower. For instance, it has to download the guide info periodically and that seems to take a long time. With cable, it was always there.



Reply With Quote