Special message from the Sheriff, Lou Blanas.
December 29, 2005
Editorial Board
P.O. Box 15779
Sacramento, CA 95852
To: Editorial Board, The Sacramento Bee
Re: “Jail Health Care- Inmates’ suffering shouldn’t be ignored”
The Bee’s editorial on December 28, 2005 entitled, “Jail Health Care – Inmates’ suffering shouldn’t be ignored,” was, like the previous articles regarding Sacramento County’s Correctional Health Services, full of inaccuracies. The most egregious error was the statement that “ Sacramento County transported inmate patients for treatment more than 7,000 times in 2004, a rate three times the state average and the highest in California.” In 2004, as in 2005, the number of inmate patients sent for treatment, including inpatient services, emergency runs and clinic visits, came to under 1,750. This number is significantlyless than the state average.
The Bee editorial also implies that Sacramento County pays either $2,070 a day at San Joaquin General Hospital, or $6,386 a day at UC Davis Medical Center for the mythical 7,000 inmate patients being sent from the jails for medical treatment. The Bee then states “Do the math.” It is obvious The Bee did not take time to do the math, because if they did, they would have realized their mistake. The rates The Bee cited in their editorial are for hospital inpatient care, which is significantly higher than the rates for emergency and clinic services. Over the last two years, an average of 240 inmate patients per year have required inpatient care, while approximately 1,500 inmates were seen as medical outpatients. The inpatient number includes field arrests, as well as referrals from the jails. It should be noted that Correctional Health Services is responsible for the medical costs incurred during field arrest even though the arrestee has not been booked in the jail. Since the beginning of the current fiscal year, 41% of all inpatient hospital costs are the result of field arrests.
Over the last two years the Sheriff’s Department has worked with the various arresting agencies in Sacramento County to reduce the cost of inmate healthcare. At one point the average cost for inpatient care was over $18,000 a day, and the average cost for an emergency room visit was over $700 dollars a day at some hospitals. This effort to reduce these costs has saved the taxpayers of Sacramento County thousand of dollars over the last couple of years.
The Bee’s statement that the health care professionals working in the jail are deliberately indifferent to the suffering of inmates is grossly inaccurate, but highly insulting to the dedicated clinicians who have chosen to work with patients who freely admit that often the only time they see a doctor or nurse is when they are incarcerated. These highly trained professionals are not only are dedicated, but like their peace officer co-workers, willingly place themselves in harms way each time they enter the jail facilities to treat those who society would rather forget.
It is extremely unfortunate when Sacramento’s only daily newspaper does not take the time to get the facts before printing an editorial that is totally inaccurate, and demeans the professionalism of over 100 doctors and nurses.
We request a retraction, or at the very least, a correction of the facts in your editorial printed on December 28, 2005.
Very Truly Yours,
Lou Blanas, Sheriff