Both routes have their pros and cons. Why not go reserves and go for a local/state job after college. Keep in mind though, that some majors are sought after more by some federal agencies. That could preclude you from needing either.
Do you consider yourself military material? There is no amount of money that can make that route worthwhile. You have to want it. I went the military route, getting a couple MOS certs as enlisted and then going ROTC. The experience helped prepare me as a person more than it really helped me get the job. Now, that I have the job, I find me experiences from the military invaluable.
I work with friends that did both, as well as friends that did neither. You'll find a little of everything. Neither is essential, but both can really be an asset.
The only part of my career that I can say military really helped a lot was in selection for Special Operations Group. The guys without military had a rougher time on things many of us took for granted. Most still excelled, but some things really put them on their heals. Whether it was the sleep deprivation, ruck runs, making the bed (believe it or not), etc. The militaristic environment just had less surprises for those of us that have been through it before.
We bring evil things to evil people, kicking in a door near you!
."In theory, there is no difference between theory and practice. But,
in practice, there is."
- Jan L.A. van de Snepscheut
"The difference between 'involvement' and 'commitment' is like
an eggs-and-ham breakfast: the chicken was 'involved' - the pig
was'committed'."
-unknown
Working on a PhD in CQB one doorway at a time.
When the wolf attacks, he will find not all who run with the flock are sheep!