Same here in NY....no crime at this point. Until the credit cards are used.....civil matter. The property was not taken by force or decption, they were dropped. Thus, we take reporst for crimes. There is no crime here is NY for dropping something in a public area and going back and not fining it. To be honest, you probably would have got the same response here, but we would have taken your name and number in the rare event it was later turned in. Now, once the cards are used somewhere...it is a crime and we will take a report IN PERSON.
We will take a courtesy report for "lost property" if you come into our station in person. They are usually done 99% of the time for cell phones only.....since many companies require you report such. But if you can justify why you need it, e might take it in such a case if you have a need for teh report (insurance claim).
-In God we trust. All others, put your hands on the car and don't move.